We Make Life Sweet
You know that feeling you get when your taste buds are happy?
That’s what happens to every person who stops by Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co.
Our baked goods are made fresh
every day with the the finest, most delicious, local ingredients.
Order your custom cookies from us for your special event, or as a treat for someone sweet.
Nothing shows you care more
than a beautifully decorated sugar cookie or our famous chocolate chip cookies!
We’d love to see you and serve you our bakery sweets and treats in Columbus, Indiana.
We are always happy to help and we are always open to new ideas! If you don't see something you are interested in just ask! Please contact us for a consultation!
Oatmeal White Chocolate Cranberry
Gourmet Chocolate Chip
Stay tuned for new flavors...We are always trying new recipes! Don't hesitate to ask if you don't see what you are looking for, we would love to help!!!
Cookie of the Month
Raspberry Cream Cheese Thumbprint
A soft cream cheese cookie with a raspberry preserve center, drizzled with white chocolate.
Bubba Rose Biscuit Co. Gourmet Dog Treats!
Don't Forget to treat your favorite pup! These handmade treats are made from real, wholesome and clean ingredients. Each treat is free from preservatives, chemicals, salt, artificial flavors, colors and fillers!
We are always adding new, seasonal and holiday treats!
Adding new cupcakes weekly and on our custom order list!
Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co. is a bakery in Columbus, Indiana. When customers walk into our bakery, they’re immediately greeted by an overwhelmingly delicious smell of freshly baked treats that no one can resist! We’re a neighborhood shop, and we love bringing sweet treats to our community. All of our goods are handcrafted, baked and served with a side of love. Stop by to taste them for yourself.
Now Open Tuesday's and
Wednesday's 10-5 - Friday 10-2!!
Saturday hours posted on our Facebook and Insta pages!!